Frugal Friday’s Workwear Report: Cropped Barrel Pants

This post may contain affiliate links and Corporette® may earn commissions for purchases made through links in this post. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

A woman (upper body cropped out) wearing a black top, black barrel pants, and black heels

Our daily workwear reports suggest one piece of work-appropriate attire in a range of prices.

These barrel pants from Scoop look shockingly similar to a much more expensive pair that I purchased this summer, but with much more inclusive sizing. I was a little tentative about the barrel cut, but I’ve received more compliments on these than any other pants in my closet, so I may be looking to add another pair. If you are also on the fence, the $40 price tag and machine-washable label might entice you to give them a try.

Today, I’m wearing them with a slim-fitting cashmere sweater to balance out the more voluminous silhouette. 

The pants are $40 at Walmart and come in sizes 0-28. They’re also available in winter white. 

Sales of note for 11/6:

  • Nordstrom – Early Black Friday sale, plus get up to $1200 in Bonus Notes!
  • Ann Taylor – 40% off tops and sweaters, and 30% off suiting, jackets and shoes
  • Athleta – Up to 60% off and extra 30% off sale
  • Banana Republic – 40% off full-priced purchase (including suits!)
  • Banana Republic Factory – 50% off everything
  • Boden – 15% off full price styles with code
  • Evereve – Extra 20% off clearance (ends Sun. 11/15)
  • J.Crew – More is more sale – 20-30% off purchases $200-$500 (including suits)
  • J.Crew Factory – 50% off sitewide, and extra 15% off orders $100+
  • M.M.LaFleur – Black Friday Preview Event! Lots of suiting marked down 10-20%. (Try code CORPORETTE15 for 15% off on other items)
  • Talbots – 50% off one item, 40% off everything else
  • Theory – Save on select coats and sweaters
  • Veronica Beard – 300+ sweaters, blazers, pants and more in their sale section

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

100 Comments

  1. I need some insight on buying a home in my 40s-50s. Partner and I are early 40s renting a small apartment in a neighborhood we adore. Our city is HCOL/ VHCOL. We’re planning to stay within the city limits for life, no plans for kids and we really like city living. When we moved here a decade ago we had hoped to buy someday. We are saving up and getting close to that goal. But I never envisioned starting a mortgage in midlife. There’s a good chance I’ll be eligible to retire before it’s paid off. Does anyone have advice on how I should plan for this, or if there’s an age you reach where taking on a mortgage doesn’t make financial sense and we should rent for life? All my friends purchased homes in the suburbs 10-15 years ago so I don’t have any clear examples of how to navigate this. Any advice for financial planning or life planning is appreciated! Anything at all we should be considering. And should we talk with some kind of specialist professional?

    1. Do everything you can to afford you new home with a 15-year mortgage. You’ll get a better interest rate than a 30-year loan, and assuming you’re ~45 you’ll be on track to pay it off when you’re ~60, so you won’t carry the debt into retirement, even if you retire fairly early.

    2. After a renting since age 19, I purchased my first home at 64, a year after I retired. Around 40% of retirees under 80 carry a mortgage. I strongly advise you to work with a financial planner. There’s a lot of emotion around home ownership but ensure your projections are sound before you make the decision. Rent vs. buy calculators are not comprehensive. I’m happy with my choice and I wish the best for you.

    3. I bought my home at age 44.
      I originally bought with a 30 year mortgage, but was able to refinance a couple of years into it for a lower interest rate as well as changing the term from 30 years to 20 years.
      The house will be paid off when I’m 68.
      I plan to retire at 65, not sure if I’ll pay off the balance then or just keep making the payments.
      Good luck!

    4. On the mortgage, if you are responsible enough to look at retiring early and have saved up for a Bay Area down payment (or equivalent), you can handle a mortgage financially. This is not about the money. For me, it was much more of an emotional thing of the permanency of the house commitment, and accepting that I couldn’t just cancel the lease if circumstances changed. It was also about just turning over all that money for a down payment. I know it’s still equity in the house, but I was kind of attached to it.

      One tip – look for places that you will be able to live in if you have to have knee surgery and have limited mobility for a couple months (… the more palatable way of saying places that you can age in place).

      1. Last sentence: so true.

        BUT: I think having a 2-story house let my parents live in it until their 80s. Mobility is sort of use-it or lose it, no? But you want a wide bathroom with wide doors off of a wide hallway if you ever need to start living downstairs. So look at that and how reliable the elevators seem to be and how wide they are (from an EMT: a good elevator fits a stretcher and two attendants; not all are like that and you don’t want to be carried down stairs because you will be too scared to call 911 when you need to).

    5. To me, entering retirement with a fixed-rate mortgage seems less risky than entering retirement knowing you will be renting forever and that rents will continue to rise. You can try for a 15-year mortgage or can pay off the balance of the mortgage at retirement too.

      1. My friend, a happy lifelong renter in a VHCOL, just bought a condo looking ahead to retirement for exactly this reason. She did get a 15-year mortgage, but retirement is less than 15 years away for her, so she will still have a mortgage for a while after. She saw it as limiting financial risk for a time of life where she may be more vulnerable.

      2. I agree with the concept that a mortgage with a known payment is less risky than rents that could keep increasing, and landlords that could evict you at any time. However my advice would be to take out a 30 year mortgage, but run your own amortization and pay on it as though it were a 15-year mortgage. That way if anything untoward happens to your finances, permanently or temporarily, you will be able to make the lower scheduled payments if you need to.

        1. This is good advice. Also co-signing the idea that a mortgage in retirement is not just normal but it can also be an inflation hedge amid rising rents. Just don’t buy more space than you actually need (due to property tax implications) and prioritize something in good condition with reasonable upkeep.

    6. I am three years away from retirement. I wanted to have my home paid off by that time, but I got divorced and life happened. As long as I can afford my mortgage in retirement (I can) I am fine with having a mortgage.

    7. I feel that if you were content to rent until your final days, I don’t see why a mortgage is any different. You’d have a house payment or a house payment. Even if prices are stable, your cost is spread over 30 (or however many years) and just your taxes and insurance go up.

      AND if your mortgage (that you got at 50) is too expensive when you are 65, you know you could refinance the remaining balance into another 30, which will tremendously lower the payments. You can get a 30 when you’re 80 (a friend’s mom did this). Assuming rates don’t skyrocket and you don’t hoover money out when you refi, I still think it’s the conservative approach.

    8. Potentially in a similar situation, what’s the downside to not paying off the mortgage before you die? Assuming that you are not leaving a partner or children in the lurch.

      1. Partner would still need a home even if you rented though, no? Or is it worry about a 2010 scenario where they can’t sell but need to move (or would need to bring money to the table because the house is underwater)?

        Life insurance to get you through your working years may actually be the answer to provide for liquidity and a smooth transition.

    9. I wouldn’t worry about a mortgage, it’s not different from rent – you have to pay housing costs. At least with owning you still build equity and have something to see if you ever need assisted living. I don’t think your age matters.

    10. I honestly have never thought about it, I don’t recognize paying off a mortgage as a goal. The $ does better % in index funds than the interest rate of the debt. And there are still property taxes and maintenance fees even if paid off, I think WSJ just had something on that. A lot of retirees get a second mortgage too.

    11. I bought my condo in the Bay Area at 50. Did a 30 year with the expectation that I’d either refi or sell and use it for another home.

      I think another important consideration is home maintenance on a fixed income. But you have to weigh that against rising rents and few renter protections. Getting a 30% rent increase is not uncommon, and think about what rents were 15 years ago. They will continue to climb in a VHCOL city.

    12. One question for you: are you and partner married? Asking because if half of a married couple dies while owning a house the other half inherits it with no taxes due and no problems (in general). I don’t know what happens if two unmarried people own a house together and one person dies, but I would definitely discuss it with a lawyer to make sure you’re both protected.

      1. We are married, thanks for pointing this out! And thanks to everyone for the valuable advice!

    13. I think there are two financial issues here.
      First, if you mortgage the effective payment will decrease over time. That is, rent goes up with inflation while a mortgage does not. (Property tax and insurance do rise, of course.)
      The second is the opportunity cost of the down payment. If you put $100k down then you’re essentially buying a bond at the current mortgage interest rate. That’s money you can’t put into a more lucrative, but probably riskier, investment. Whether this is a good idea or not depends on the details of your financial situation but I think this is the way to frame the question.

    14. True for everyone, but especially if you’re looking at retirement: consider climate change and the insurability of your property going forward. Fire, flood, storms—whatever is more likely in your area. You want to be spared from dramatic increases in insurance costs or just not being able to buy insurance.

    15. Other people covered the financial issues, but I want to point out that owning where you want to live prevents you from being displaced if prices increase later. I know an older couple that rented the same unit for 20+ years that had to move in their 60s and 70s. Home prices went up dramatically and the building owner decided to sell. They could no longer afford the rents in the area and had to move away from their friends to a suburb 45 minutes away.

      My mother was also forced to move from an apartment she loved because the building increased rents by over $500 per month. Many other residents had to move out too.

    16. When I got divorced at 55 I didn’t hesitate for a moment before buying a house with a mortgage. As others have said, you have housing costs no matter what and owning gives you security on several fronts that renting doesn’t.

      1. Same, at the exact age. I had a decent interest rate and then refinanced to a really low rate, so I know I was lucky, but my mortgage is about half of what rent would be now, more than 10 years later.

  2. I have to take a company headshot in a few weeks, and we are required to wear branded apparel for it (sigh). The choices were a short sleeve polo or a quarter zip pullover – I chose the quarter zip because I hate polo collars, but now I’m not sure what to wear under it. It’s navy and our logo is mostly white with a little gold on the left chest area. I definitely need to wear something under it, but should the undershirt be visible? If so, how far should I leave it unzipped and what color should it be? Thanks, all!

      1. And I would add prominent earrings and a pearl choker or small silk scarf to signal that I am a woman, and not a finance bro. As a woman, I refuse to allow required corporate styles to turn me into a generic man. [Not that there’s anything wrong with that…..]

        1. No, no no. You cannot wear a co11ared shirt or a scarf or pearls or big earrings with a quarter-zip unless you want to look like a frumpy old lady who is out of place. Just wear a crewneck tee in a color that isn’t bright white (light grey or pale blue would work well) and zip the quarter-zip to whatever height looks best in the mirror.

          1. You do you. A tee or cami under a quarter-zip makes me feel like a youth volleyball coach shepherding two dozen tweens on a flight.

          2. Yes, I think those items would look fussy and frumpy and don’t match the casual level. I’m also scratching my head over the comment that said to wear a button down. How would that even work? The collar would be so awkward under the quarter zip. I think a shirt underneath that matches for little contrast to avoid drawing attention to it is best here.

            Do your hair and makeup in a way that you like, choose nice (but not fancy) earrings and you’re set.

          3. Do what college athletes do for their official photos and wear the sporty uniform with fancy hair and makeup.

    1. I would wear a navy silk shell or cami underneath just in case it’s visible. I like the zipper to be below the collarbone by an inch or two. My focus would be on a nice lip color and earrings.

    2. Wear something under so you don’t look nakkey. And whatever you do, don’t wear 2 quarter zips like Sean Duffy.

    3. Cami that doesn’t really show and a delicate necklace (or layered delicate necklaces, if that’s your vibe).

  3. Halp, fellow midlife women. My foundation is not looking as good as it used to, even though I’m using a formula that’s supposedly good for mature skin. I have always gone for demi-matte or satin finishes because those are the ones that LAST on my skin. I keep reading dewy is better for us, but with my combo skin (still!), dewy looks awful and greasy by mid-day. Serum formulas and BB creams are tough in terms of finding a good color match. I’m cool with pink undertones and so many of the lighter formulations are way too warm. I have to go to the far end of fair to get anything pinky, and then I look like the crypt keeper.

    I don’t feel comfortable going without some sort of base — just too much natural ruddiness even though my skin is good overall.

    1. So, the actual question: Do you have any recommendations? Currently using NARS, and even the cool tones are a little warmer than I’d like.

      1. I’m usually a sucker for the high-end makeup brands, but I found the Maybelline Fit Me foundation surprisingly forgiving to my mature skin. L’Oréal Infallible isn’t bad either. Both are cheap enough for you to experiment with. I also like the Missha M Perfect Cover BB Cream. Its coverage is like that of a foundation, but I don’t know about their color matches.

      2. Same age and concern and I like both the Dior glow foundation for heavier coverage, and the new m.PH skin serum for ‘my skin but better’ days.

    2. I am older and agree you do have to change your makeup as your skin ages. I have similar skin color as you. I have found that tinted moisturizer works better as I age (I like Laura Mercier and Bare Minerals). But lately I have been absolutely loving the tinted skin serum (L’oreal True Match), as it is very light. It’s my skin but better. I can’t stand a heavy foundation anymore.

      1. Thanks, I’ll have to look at those options. I have wasted SO MUCH MONEY on base products during the past few years. Ugh.

      1. I have mild rosacea. Once i started treating my rosacea with regular facials, gently washing my face and using rosacea friendly moisturizer, I fell in love with my Armani luminous silk. It’s not necessary most days, but makes me feel so put together. And I say this after about 5 years of not feeling like my makeup was “put together” at all – I felt like I was getting into clown territory.

    3. Lune + Aster Realglow Skin Tint. I don’t know if it’s technically a foundation or a CC cream or what, but it’s buildable coverage and looks great, and has a fairly good range of color options. I switched to it after the Clinique Even Better foundation I’d been wearing for years started looking weird on my aging skin. Bluemercury sells it if you want to go colormatch in person. Only downside (depending on your view) is it doesn’t have SPF so if you’re wearing it during the day, you’ll need a separate sunscreen (I wear Revision Intellishade Matte during the day, but it is truly just a tinted moisturizer, so not a ton of coverage).

      1. Even Better looks TERRIBLE on my skin. I actually have quite a bit of Clinique makeup, but for some reason, the foundations do not work for me.

    4. I love Ciele and it stays on all day. Also, consider using primer or a spray to make your makeup last. I also love Dior Face and Body because it stays on, I especially use it in summer when I get more sweaty.

    5. I use Dr. Jart Cicapair Soothing Color Correcting Treatment on red areas as a primer (it’s also a SPF). Then find most foundations behave better on top of it.

        1. Same. Applying with a beauty blender helps but if I’m breaking out the beauty blender I’m likely wearing full foundation.

    6. In addition to the recs I’d also strongly suggest a ‘glowy’ setting spray to help refresh your makeup once it starts to get dry.

    7. I just switched from NARS tinted moisturizer to the Ordinary serum foundation as recommended by someone here and loooooove it. The finish is so nice and doesn’t look weird in fine lines. Also it was like $7 !!

    8. I have rosacea, so red undertones and sensitive skin, and just switched to Jones Road because it was a better color match for me. I use both the What the Foundation for more coverage, and the tinted moisturizer for less. I don’t have particularly dry mature skin but it’s not oily. I found their online color match pretty spot on, but then I went to their store and the associate took me one shade lighter for winter. Stays on, doesn’t irritate my skin, very happy so far. I use HA5 hyaluronic serum, Obagi intensive moisturizer in the morning day and night.

    9. If you are looking to even out instead of looking for coverage, I recommend Juice Beauty’s primer. I have oily skin even in my 60’s, which is now going a bit crepey in areas. I use Fenty Invisimatte powder applied to the t zone with a fluffy brush after the primer is dry. I also use a cream concealer as needed under the primer.

    10. I am 52, and love Westman Atelier’s Supreme liquid foundation. I am a makeup lover, so feel like I have literally tried them all, and this is the best one for me (dry, sensitive skin, redness, fine lines). Expensive, but a little goes a long way, evens out my skin, feels like nothing.

  4. How do Farm Rio dresses fit if it’s a sundress style with straps that is fairly straight but loose below the bust / torso area? My favorite is still available and I have winter travel to a warm area for a beach wedding and technically “need” it. I’m usually a S but in a very loose dress / shirts. Also, do they run long? I’m 5-4 and don’t want to deal with hemming due to the detailing (so may need a mini, which is knee length on me from a sample size of 1 dress).

    1. I love Farm Rio dresses so much, but I can rarely wear them. The necklines are often plunging and too loose on top. I’d say the style you are describing tends to run large. Maybe order S and XS and return one?

      I also think the minis are a good length for your height. I am closer to 5’7″ and they’re pretty short on me.

    2. I love Farm Rio dresses! They all have very, very different fits, though. Which one? I may have worn it before. I am 5’5″ and wear the midi dresses without issue.

      Also, highly recommend renting them through nuuly. I rent 4-6 farm rio dresses for each winter beach trip.

    3. Check if it’s on Nuuly! You can rent 6 items for $70 for your first month (intro offer). They have a lot of Farm Rio options. If your dress is there, you can rent it to see if you like the fit and have others as back-ups.

  5. Help me use my words to have a difficult conversation with my parents, who want to visit us multiple times a year for a week+ each time. I’m the only child who pays attention to them, and one parent has dementia, and is codependent, and struggles with mental health issues so I’ve been hesitant to rock the boat. But I’m tired, I need my space, and it is draining to have them here for long periods of time because they don’t entertain themselves, and my spouse and I still need to manage our demanding jobs and young kids on top of entertaining, cooking, and caring for them. I’m dreading another week with them next week, and they have already started talking about their next trip to visit us. I know I’m fortunate to still have my parents around and I should just make the most of the time I have with them, especially since they live a flight away from us, but I’m struggling.

    1. It might seem counterintuitive, but can they relocate to you? My parents did that and it’s actually much better to see them in small doses more frequently rather than 24/7 togetherness for a week+. I assume the parent with dementia is going to need more care soon anyway, and it makes sense that that care would be in your city if you’re the only involved kid.

      1. Also, traveling with a spouse with dementia is hard on everyone. My friends mom wandered off on a vacatIon, and her whole family, staff, and other folks had to organize a search. It was scary.

      2. +1. Relocation to a senior living community of some kind close to you would make life easier in many ways.

      3. I also had this thought.

        If this isn’t an option, can you position the conversation more that you cannot continue to entertain them and rearrange schedules while they are visiting vs. telling them not to come at all?

        1. In my experience, that conversation will not be understood, much less followed, by someone with dementia.

          1. I mean obviously this convo would need to be had with the parent who does NOT have dementia.

      4. This is what I’m hoping to convince my parents to do in the next phase of their life for exactly this reason.

        In the short term, honestly, I would start “traveling for work” a bit more.

    2. How old are your kids? I found that as my kids got older (like late elementary school at times and then into middle / high school), they started to have a schedule (in addition to my schedule, spouse’s schedule, dog schedule). And they needed to practice driving.

      TL;DR — if we didn’t have low-need parents, we’d have told them they are welcome to visit, but they can come with us or sit at home and we will feed them, but it may be a lot of pizza and spaghetti. They need to merge into our traffic patterns or just hang out — there is no third way any more just for them. But they really wanted to just embed with us and not disturb us. They delight in just seeing us. It’s such a gift (and then time ran out and things got a lot harder, but that’s not for you right now, so you have the luxury of time to reset things).

    3. We love to see you but with our busy schedules, hosting you in our house isn’t a viable option. Here are some local hotels. We can have you over for dinner on Tuesday and Thursday. You are welcome to watch Susie’s soccer game on Monday, Jim’s trombone concerto on Wednesday, and let us know if you want to join us for the library trip on Saturday.

      1. I don’t think you can use that script at all in this situation – that’s a script you use for a distant aunt who would like to visit for the first time in years, not your parents who have regularly stayed with you for a week for a long time. I’d try:

        “Mom, Dad, you know how much I love visiting with you, but with the kids getting older and work cranking up, hosting you for a week has become more challenging. What would you think about me coming to you for a four-day weekend in the spring instead of you coming here for spring break?” would be where I’d start.

        1. Unless you have babies, the family schedule should not stop for week-long family visitors (and with babies, their schedule is their schedule, period). They aren’t really guests but family members, and I don’t think that you need to “host” them, just cook more for the meals you’d eat otherwise if they are at your house and have food on hand for easy lunches.

          If they are expecting you to drop everything and host them (the way you might if you were hosting a new BF or a visiting guest you invited or someone staying with you for a local funeral where nothing is planned in advance), it’s time to retrain them and reset expectations. Lilly has swim practice and Davis has tuba lessons and you have a client dinner and sanity you need to keep.

    4. So it’s a parent with dementia, and a caretaker parent?

      This whole situation sounds really, really hard, because of the dementia. The caretaker parent probably desperately needs this respite of being with you for these weeks. And you are staggering under the load as well. Is there a longer-term plan in place for when the dementia progresses beyond what the caretaker parent can handle? To be honest, I’d put your emotional / boundaries energy into those conversations, or into helping the caretaker parent find a different way to get a weeks’ respite, because this situation is naturally going to get worse, not better. (I’m so sorry; it’s brutal.)

    5. So one parent is a primary caregiver to their partner with dementia?

      It sounds like that parent needs respite care but doesn’t ask for it. What assistance do they have in the home? And I say in the home because not every older adult wants to live in assisted living (or can actually afford it). It sounds like you have siblings who need to figure out how mom and dad are getting caregiving.

      I’m sure it’s exhausting as caregiving is. I’m very empathetic because I’ve done it many times. The reality is that the burden of caregiving increases the likeliness that your parent without dementia will die first. What will you all do at that point? It’s time to have hard conversations.

  6. I literally just bought these pants yesterday (with the matching cropped jacket!) and love them. Very comfy ponte fabric in a unique silhouette.

  7. What shoes are we wearing with the cropped baggy pants at the office? At home I’d wear low rise sneakers but I’m stumped on a work appropriate shoe. Flats + barrel leg, or wide leg cropped look like floods on me.

    1. I usually wear flat or low-heel boots. The key is that the shaft needs to be high enough to be under the hemline when standing. Sometimes I wear oxfords or flat loafers with socks.

      1. I want to like oxfords but associate tie shoes for women with those dreadful “jazz” shoes that I wore as my fancy shoes in middle school (don’t ask; IIRC they were the actual suede-bottomed ones from Capezio). And I can never figure out the sock / footwear situation.

        1. I hear you (and had the shoes). I tend to prefer oxfords with a little heel–say, 1-2″. Sort of a retro look that reminds me of the “sensible” shoes my grandma wore. I usually wear thin socks that match or come close to the shoe color, but sometimes I go for stripes.

    2. Doc Martin-ish boots are what I wear. It’s a bit angry of a look, but I don’t like winter anyway. Lets me wear warm fuzzy socks.

    3. Lug sole boots in the winter, pointy toed boots if it’s a dressier winter look, or loafers in the fall/spring/summer.

  8. Is AYR for short people? All of the models look super thin and tall and I’m wondering if its even worth it to order something. (I’m 5′ 2″)

      1. Yeah, I was also wondering about all their tops though. Will they look ridiculously oversized on my short frame?

  9. With all the sales coming up can anyone recommend an at-home IPL specifically for facial hair. Especially if you are very hairy like me! I don’t need it for rest of body (well, I just don’t care). Please drop your recs here. Hoping for a deal!

  10. PSA – Leset has 25% off everything right now, which includes their perfect tee, the Margo. No code needed.