Thursday’s Workwear Report: Tie-Neck Sweater
This post may contain affiliate links and Corporette® may earn commissions for purchases made through links in this post. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Our daily workwear reports suggest one piece of work-appropriate attire in a range of prices.
This tie-neck sweater from Wit & Wisdom looks like a cozy and cute option for fall, and it’s available in petites! A friend recently complained about the dearth of petite-sized tops available for officewear, so it’s been on my radar even more than usual. I like the cable-knit details on the sleeves, and the tie neck gives it a little something extra.
I would wear this with a midi skirt and boots on a chilly day.
The sweater is $84 at Nordstrom and comes in sizes XS-XL and XSP-XLP.
Sales of note for 11/6:
- Nordstrom – Early Black Friday sale, plus get up to $1200 in Bonus Notes!
- Ann Taylor – 40% off tops and sweaters, and 30% off suiting, jackets and shoes
- Athleta – Up to 60% off and extra 30% off sale
- Banana Republic – 40% off full-priced purchase (including suits!)
- Banana Republic Factory – 50% off everything
- Boden – 15% off full price styles with code
- Evereve – Extra 20% off clearance (ends Sun. 11/15)
- J.Crew – More is more sale – 20-30% off purchases $200-$500 (including suits)
- J.Crew Factory – 50% off sitewide, and extra 15% off orders $100+
- M.M.LaFleur – Black Friday Preview Event! Lots of suiting marked down 10-20%. (Try code CORPORETTE15 for 15% off on other items)
- Talbots – 50% off one item, 40% off everything else
- Theory – Save on select coats and sweaters
- Veronica Beard – 300+ sweaters, blazers, pants and more in their sale section

I am not feeling very happy with my fall/winter work wardrobe. I want to create something of a uniform for myself that is very comfortable but still polished. Most days are at my desk and my workplace is on the business casual end. I would like to wear sneakers, pants with stretch (preferably faux buttons and zippers) in straight or bootcut styles, and a sweater or quarter zip on top that doesn’t look frumpy. Am I reaching for the stars here? Do you have any of these items that you like?
I just bought two of the Banana Republic cotton-silk crewneck sweaters. I think I’m going to get a ton of mileage out of them this winter. They look good with both denim and dress pants.
For sneakers, the Ecco Soft 7 in leather is my work-appropriate version.
I can’t help with pants, as I’m also searching!
In case it’s relevant — I bought the black and mauve sweaters. The port red is also gorgeous.
Quince cashmere sweaters are inexpensive and would serve your needs.
Also, Maeve Magic Fabric pants (from Anthro) are stretchy and comfortable.
True. I have 7 of their cashmere cardigans that I wear most days. I wear them buttoned up with an undershirt, or over a collared silk blouse, also with an undershirt, because I’m not willing to launder delicates that frequently.
FWIW I’ve found the quality of Quince cashmere to be terrible– horrible pilling after one or two wears without washing, doesn’t keep its shape if you push your sleeves up (even just to wash your hands!). They sent me a replacement after I left a fair but negative review, and the replacement was exactly as poor quality as the first one. They also removed my review.
Agree, they are dreadful quality and seem more focused on managing their reputation through marketing vs simply improving product quality.
I’m sorry that happened to you, but for an $80 price tag, my cardigans are holding up fine.
TBH, I think this will look frumpy, or at least very boring, unless the sweater or pants are particularly interesting and your hair and other personal grooming is really well-done. Boring is fine, to be clear, but if that’s not your goal, I’d consider adding a third piece: a belt, collared shirt layered under the sweater, or a scarf, or swapping the sweater for a blazer + shirt combo.
+1. Especially with sneakers I can’t imagine how this will look polished.
If the pants are well-tailored, hemmed to the perfect length for the shoes, and without an elastic waist, the sneakers are current, and the sweater is cut just right, it will look fabulous. Boots would be better.
With elastic-waist pants and a dumpy sweater, it will be frump city.
I wear some version of a button up, sweater and jeans and sneakers most days. Today it’s a stand collar striped button up with a lady jacket with cropped cream colored jeans and some retro Nikes in bright yellow. Yesterday, it was black straight legs and a black turtleneck with a striped charcoal button up peaking out and animal print pumas.
The secret to the formula, for me at least, is a few more interesting pieces. You can see I like fun sneakers. I have utility jeans, barrel jeans and statement pants. I like a stripe on my button ups. The polish comes from great fit and good condition. If the shirts aren’t pressed crisp, if sneakers look worn out or if the sweaters get pills, the whole thing is frump city.
I love both of these outfits!
I like Cole Haan sneakers for work. I buy in person, so I don’t know the names.
My favorite work pants right now are Banana Republic Factory Hayden pants. They pretend to be trousers and have real pockets, but the back waistband is elastic. I wear the wide leg version.
For the top, I think you need short sleeve sweaters and a mix of interesting blazers, or a set of interesting long sleeve sweaters. My blazers are mostly from “nice” resale/thrift stores. I rent sweaters from nuuly so I’m not wearing the same thing all fall and winter.
I like merino wool sweaters. I also love turtlenecks. I love good fall colors like rich browns, reds, purples, and greens. Sometimes blue but most of my bottoms are black so would the tops should not be too dark. I have had good luck with J crew and banana. For higher end I got a really nice one (thrifted) from Vince.
If voluminous bottoms, slim fit tops.
If voluminous tops, fitted bottoms (but straight legs, not skinny).
I like cropped/ankle length pants with sneakers but I don’t know if that’s actually cute or just my eye.
Barrel cut are surprisingly flattering.
I bought the Wit and Wisdom barrel pants after seeing them on Corporette, and I will be living in them all fall/winter: https://corporette.com/best-barrel-pants-for-work/
Super comfortable waist, size down.
Associates interviewing in person at midsize law firms- does anyone greet you in the beginning before your interview or see you off at the end? And specifically at the end of the interview- do you just leave after your interview is finished, or does someone from HR come out and tell you about next steps, etc?
At our mid-sized firm, an interviewing associate would meet the receptionist, who would summon the attorneys interviewing the candidate. The attorneys then interview the candidate, answer any questions about next steps, then escort the candidate to the door to depart.
IME – more in-house than firms now – typically the last interviewer walks you out. Sometimes there is confusion about whether they need to get you back to HR/some other contact, but typically that’s resolved by (1) the interviewer reaching out to HR/etc. or (2) if the drop off to HR happens, it’s usually just “OK, thanks for coming in!” No substantive update because they don’t know how the interview went yet. Basically, I wouldn’t assume a formal “closeout” of the interview with information that day.
In most mid-sized firms I’ve interviewed with, the receptionist will greet you and the last attorney to interview you will take you to the door. You don’t usually meet with HR.
In my current (large) firm, candidates meet with the “associate development coordinator” or whatever her job title is now (I feel like it’s always changing) at the beginning of the interview. I don’t think they also meet at the end.
This sweater also comes in a nice, dark charcoal grey. I think I may order. I think it would look pretty with a skirt *or* pants.
Intriguing! I’ve been looking for a good charcoal sweater.
So cute and not made of itchy wool! If I could pull off ruffles and bows I would definitely buy it.
I need some v comfy v versatile party shoes with a reasonable heel. Thinking silver but flexible. Suggestions?
Wirecutter had an article about comfortable heels yesterday. Not sure if the link will work but here it is:
https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/most-comfortable-heels/
The Racer heel they review comes in silver.
Following! I also need a shoe like this
I have these in two colors and VERY comfortable. I wear them to weddings. And I don’t wear heels any more, but these work for me.
https://www.zappos.com/p/womens-cole-haan-josie-block-heel-sandal-65-mm-silver-leather/product/9623691/color/3298?utm_source=google&utm_medium=pla_x&utm_campaign=23709491238&utm_term=_o_60736034&utm_content=_g__w__l_EAIaIQobChMIlM7cqcTflwMVzy1ECB1fWScmEAQYASABEgKXlfD_BwE&gbraid=0AAAAADnIwa8O22lEZSb6a-OCg0sNDcTcx&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIlM7cqcTflwMVzy1ECB1fWScmEAQYASABEgKXlfD_BwE
Oh good thread. My broken in classic wedding heels just broke.
I have a Naturalizer strappy, block-heel sandal that fits the bill – I’ve worn to multiple weddings (including as a bridesmaid) and they’re super comfortable. The style I have is the Bristol, those appear to be discontinued but the Izzy looks pretty similar.
I would like to buy some jewelry to add a little something to my basic work pieces. I’m not looking for heirloom quality stuff — just a few stylish pieces that I can wear for the next 3-5 years. Any ideas of where to look? I don’t wear large, chunky jewelry, but I still want something that has some presence.
What’s the neckline of an outfit you have in mind? Otherwise stick to earrings. Bracelets get too fussy.
Me, I get the most mileage out of gold rope chains. I have a 2 mm 15 inch, and a 6 mm 30 inch that I sometimes pair with a 30 inch pearl necklace.
I agree with the other commenter. Earrings first. I like bracelets, and necklaces are hardest. I have a 16″ delicate gold chain I wear, but I get the least mileage out of necklaces bc my shirts have all different necklines.
That’s the challenge for me. I feel like I can wear shorter necklaces (< 24") in the summer when I am wearing more open necklines. And for winter when I'm cold, I need a longer necklace (and like that I can put a 24" one over my head vs fiddling with a clasp). If you wear necklaces, please post your tips. I have two necklaces from Jet Set Candy that I love in theory but cannot wear (especially the paper clip link charm holder one — it always looks off balance). Maybe the problem is me.
Paper clip chains look weird on me, too, as does any chain that needs to lay flat.
I prefer mine shorter and higher on the neck, that way it isn’t playing too oddly with my neckline. Re clasps, I get magnet clasps for my shorter chains.
Necklace and bracelet hack – buy some magnetic clasps in silver or gold (depending on the color of your jewelry). It makes quick work of throwing on jewelry in the morning, even when I’m indecisive.
Oh — I am really not an earring person. Necklaces are more useful to me.
Look at Mejuri for nicer jewelry that’s not ridiculously expensive.
My favorite jewelry comes from museum gift shops.
Find a good bench jeweler where you live and start there. Mine specializes in antique and vintage and that’s always more bang for the buck.
I really like Jenny Bird and I get compliments on it.
I really like Julia Szendrei jewelry–it’s real gemstones, good prices and I always get compliments!
Oh my, these are gorgeous pieces. Way outside my budget, but beautiful.
I agree with the rec for museum shops and would also look at local artisan shops or crafts fair. The piece of jewelry I get the most compliments on is a small-ish jasper pendant (maybe 1″ x 1.5″) that I got from a booth at a festival. I have several pendants that I wear on a plain silver chain, as well as some chunkier (but not huge) bead and stone pieces. The one in most regular rotation at the moment is a simplified representation of the molecular structure of serotonin; I bought it from a local maker in San Juan, PR who does not seem to have a website, but I think you can find the on Etsy and elsewhere.
I rely on necklace extenders to change the length of a necklace to work with different necklines.
I have an adjustable-length pendant necklace from women-owned Bronwen Jewelry that I really love–and the adjustability makes it so useful! Might be not as fancy as you want.
Do you like your robot vacuum? If so, which one do you have? This is not for me, and robot vac vs. no robot vac is not the question; she’s asked for it very specifically, she is hard to buy for, and she’s getting it. Budget is $500. Amazon reviews are making me crazy.
Are these comments ads for robot vacuums? Suspicious.
You should reset your suspicion meter.
Roomba, the one which has a storage unit which allows less frequent emptying/refilling (if also a mop). If it’s appropriate, include set up as part of the gift (like if it’s for a parent etc).
Thanks. I’ll look for the highest-capacity Roomba.
I’m very happy with my old, dumb roomba. It has no wifi, no mop, no camera, no app, no massive charging station.
It does exactly what I want, it putters around vacuuming anything in its way, with no sophistication or plan. It’s small and low enough to go under beds and sofas. Perfect.
Every six months or so I change the rotary brush.
Thanks!
I just had a conversation about this at lunch. I love my 705 Roomba, but my co-worker is having a rough time with his Roomba vacuum/mopper. I think the main difference is how we use it. I leave mine in one space where it vacuums my kitchen, entryway and dining room 3x a week without human intervention or thought. My coworker moves his around. He also just suffered through some kind of software update that made him lose all his maps.
Wait for black Friday if possible. They usually go on sale.
Just popping in to say I’ve had excellent luck buying open box models from the ‘zon at basically a 50% or more discount.
Favorite semi-opaque tights that come in control top options? I’m thinking like 40 denier range.
I like Calzedonia’s tights, they have lots of options and have sales frequently. I just re-purchased 3 pairs of black denier 20 (w/o control top) with a buy 2 get 1 free sale. They last a reasonably long time for tights if you are careful with rings and nails.
This isn’t helpful, but damn I miss DKNY tights!
marks and spencer. They ship to the US from the UK. The Brits know tights, and they’re not expensive!
I have a cotton/merino sweater that is too large and too long (lucky-ish find on clearance). If I wash it, might it shrink a bit (but in a uniform way)? Or are there other tricks to slightly shrinking something on purpose? I have also thought of spritzing with water and putting it into the dryer and checking every 5 minutes or so.
this will not work. it will not shrink uniformly. slouchy can be in if properly styled or sell it on poshmark. and in the kindest way if it doesn’t fit it isn’t a lucky find.
Haha, seconding that this will not work. I just did this (wrongly) over the weekend. And I am definitely old enough to know better.
No, not a thing. You will just ruin your sweater.
So if you wash merino, it will shrink, by felting. So the material will get stiffer and less polished looking.
If that’s what you’re after, warm/hot water + agitation will get you felted.
If you’re probably not going to wear it as it is, I’d say go for it. Start with a warm water wash to see how much the length draws up. If it seems good lengthwise but is now too narrow, put your arms in the sweater and spread them gently to widen it, then drape on a drying rack to dry. If it shrank some but not enough, put it on the drying rack, let it get nearly dry, and while it is still damp stretch it if you need to width wise then throw it in the dryer (wrong side out) with some dry towels or something for just a little while on gentle. I’ve lost a lot of weight and have successfully done an artful shrink of Brooks Brothers cashmere because I didn’t want to pay for new and the new is lower quality than what I have.
For people currently in graduate / professional school, how are you managing paying for school now? It is just making up the gap with private loans, maybe with getting a co-signer? I was thinking about going for an other degree and that I could borrow what I haven’t saved or gotten a scholarship for, but now I am not sure how feasible that is. Would be looking at state schools and while tuition is low, cost of living can be high (or high for a FT student).
I went at night FT (program geared to working mid-career professionals) and paid cash as I went. No freaking way was I going to take out loans, had enough of sticker shock for undergrad.
How much in loans are you talking about?
And maybe, what’s *your* cost of living? I think this is pretty stage of life/personal choices (and some school factors). I did a ft master’s degree in a high COL area inexpensively, but living like a broke student (dorms, and then several roommates, cheap school based catastrophic health insurance I couldn’t afford to use, free food from events) – different calculus if you actually need healthcare, want your own apartment, etc
Finding a job at a company that offers tuition reimbursement and doing grad school part time. It takes longer and you won’t have much free time but you won’t end up with a pile of debt.
This is what my daughter is doing. She got a job (administrative job but requires a bachelors) at the university which provides tuition reimbursement and is working on a master’s degree part time. The pay is pretty low but with a roommate is doable.
When I did my graduate degree, I worked for the university I got it from. I took the job despite its low pay for exactly this reason my husband paid for his graduate school with a combination of a merit grant from the graduate school.
, working part time during school at the job he was leaving, his summer (paid) internship, and loans for the rest.
At a minimum, I would recommend you work enough to cover your basic living expenses and if you absolutely must take out loans do it only for the portion of tuition you can’t cover in cash definitely don’t borrow for a living expenses unless you see a very short term ROI on this degree. Graduate school is a lot of work, but you have plenty of free time for a job. Heck, you could babysit for $20-$30 per hour cash under the table if you live near me!
Working full time and slowly going to school full time while attending the cheapest decent local program.
I’m going to be in Boston for a few days next week and have an open day Saturday. Staying near Boston Commons and don’t plan to have a car. I’d love recommendations for restaurants, cafes, shops, and attractions worth seeing. My husband really wants to have seafood, so I’d love the scoop on what’s worth it and what to skip. I haven’t been to Boston since the late 1980s, so I have zero context. TIA!
Enjoy, the weather looks gorgeous next week! You’re close to pretty much everything there. Unfortunately some of the most interesting food in Boston isn’t in the city center, and it’s really not a ‘foodie’ city so maybe adjust expectations accordingly. For seafood Saltie Girl, Atlantic Fish Co. are reliable but $$. Neptune’s in the North End is amazing but doesn’t take reservations so the wait times are long. I love Mama Maria’s if you like Italian. There are a bunch of Tatte and Flour Locations near there, I prefer Flour over Tatte but both are good.
The Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum is my top suggestion if you like art, otherwise the Freedom trail is a great option as it’s self guided/pop-in pop-out.
Neptune Oyster. It’s tiny but you can usually sit at the bar. Great seafood.
Thank you both!
Row 34 for Seafood!
I would take a nice walk in the Public Garden (it’s the part with the lagoon, although it may be drained right around now) over to Charles Street in Beacon Hill. Get coffee at Tatte and wander. Consider walking to the Esplanade on the Charles River.
Alternatively, rent a car and go apple picking outside the City. It’s SO FUN this time of year!
Facing down another year of paltry COL raise, a ‘meets expectations’ rating (while my wider department got slashed and burned and I did the work of multiple people), and was just turned down for an internal promotion. Overall it’s worth staying where I am as the job market is so dire but I’m just feeling so beaten down.
Advice? Commiseration? Share your stories of woe! (sorry Shots! Shots! Shots! but my 45 year old system can’t handle you any longer).
I wouldn’t waste my energy getting worked up by the status quo. That’s not a real problem. If you got a performance is bad and about to be fired, that’s a real problem. A middle of the road, normal review where you have a job? Just accept it. If you’re more ambitious than this company, start making a plan.
I disagree. The opportunity cost for lost salary is substantial – millions once the compounding interest of 20 years before OP’s retirement – and it builds up faster than we realize. That’s a very real problem
Agreed, plus the very real risk of burnout, financial stress about not having enough income while costs rise, etc. Those are all very real.
Lol—stop pretending a raise is in the cards just because we want it.
So true. You are not entitled to constant raises, just as companies themselves are not entitled to constant profit increases. If you are unhappy, you must make the effort to find another job.
It’s rough out there!
This is hard to get the tone right but, I do find it helpful to reflect on how absolutely wildly wealthy I am (at about US median) than the vast majority of people who have ever lived. I have colleagues (formerly in international development) whose whole family, to second cousin’s, chipped in to get them through college, and now… their industry doesn’t exist, and all of those relatives who pinned the families’ hopes on them are disappointed. When they talk about food insecurity, they mean literally not enough calories available, not the US definition. They don’t have the option of “oh, if my govt keeps getting more authoritarian, maybe I just move to Canada”.
I am 99% preaching to myself here though, not you. It’s legit to be frustrated (I was laid off, searched madly for over a year, and eventually got a job for a 30% pay cut and a 90 minute commute each way). But I’m also still pretty freaking lucky
Definitely dust off your resume and apply to other jobs! Yes, it’s brutal out there, but it’s easier to find a job when you have a job, and you could end up with a raise at the new place!
In a similar boat – my boss is making up excuse after excuse not to give me a raise she admits I deserve (??) and I just started officially job searching, but I’m very concerned about finding anything thanks to DOGE and AI. Our costs are very high and we just found out our health insurance plan is getting discontinued so they’re about to get higher. I’m having some fun entertaining elaborate quitting fantasies, though.
It’s rough out there, so I understand your pain. I’m a year into a new role after a re-org that has me basically doing 3 people’s jobs. I hate it. But the pickings are slim, and I’m picky, so I’m biding my time.
I have two coping mechanisms: First, I low-key job hunt all the time – I’ve activated my network and do a scan of competitor’s job boards and the dreaded linkedin postings while on remote meetings that I can half-ass. My resume is up to date and I have a calendar reminder to refresh it quarterly. When the right job appears, I’m ready to go.
Second, I am leaning out intentionally. Everyone is aware that the re-org left too much on my plate and few people for me to delegate to, so I extend timelines and underpromise all the time. In my current context, it’s strategically useful for me to do this openly, but that may not be true in your case. Know your office. But the risk of burnout is very real, and I’m just not willing to contribute more than I have to an organization that isn’t rewarding me in kind.
+1. I just posted above about not getting a raise and beginning job searching and should have added that I am also leaning out. I’ll still do excellent work but it will not be above and beyond or at times when it’s inconvenient for me. I will no longer volunteer to lead anything extra or work the occasional weekend to win new work – that is now the domain of the people getting paid $40K-100K more than I am despite us sharing responsibilities.
This is the way.
If you don’t feel up to job searching yet, I’d at least look at roles you’d want to do, check that the comp package is what you’re expecting, and start getting as much relevant experience as you can to help position you to land the roles want in the medium term.
If your company offers tuition reimbursement or other training opportunities, take advantage of it. Go to events such as conferences to expand your network. If you can, volunteer for something useful which aligns with your medium or long term goal.
Do things outside of work which fill your bucket; yoga, walking at lunch time, meeting up with friends, etc.
Sounds like you’re also a Fed? I’m so sorry everything sucks.
Yup, I’m lucky in that I wasn’t hit by DOGE but my husband was. So much for federal jobs being the safe and stable choice!
What do you do to treat yourself when you are going through a tough and stressful time that includes being extremely busy, not wanting to spend a lot of unnecessary money, and and wanting to eat reasonably healthy (for me this includes little to no caffeine)?
Nail polish or lipstick. The classics.
Spending more money on buying ebooks or tv shows so that I have instant access.
Clothes shopping honestly.
More practically things like a cleaning person, meal kit or just general grocery delivery, sending laundry out
My favourite treat is going for a long walk by the water watching all the critters and sunset. It feels so nice to just take an hour for me. I don’t text or check my phone the whole time. Its me, my thoughts, and nature(ish, the river runs right through the city but the path is pretty green).
meal prep service/prepped meals from a healthy source, if you’d otherwise end up cooking or doing unhealthy takeout? Finding time for a special fitness class you might not otherwise make time for? Being very deliberate about carving out time for yourself – e.g., if your role allows, maybe it’s saying “I’m not going to check my email at all on Sunday.”
I splurge on sashimi. It’s pricey but not unhealthy.
Sitting outside *without my phone* with a cup of herbal tea for 10 minutes is a go-to treat for me. Not multitasking (hence the no phone) feels luxurious
I try to squeeze in walks and baths, mostly. A few minutes outdoors particularly helps.
Someone here introduced me to Yasso Greek Yogurt Bars. If you do want a food treat, they’re quite good and much healthier than ice cream. I like the chocolate coated ones.
A care service I would normally do myself, such as a manicure or pedicure. A facial or massage if you’re into that.
A long mountain bike ride, ideally in slightly cold or uncomfortable conditions, so coming home, showering, and getting into bed with a book and my cat feels that much sweeter.
We can debate unnecessary money threshold but – if you really need a pick me up, the LV lip gloss. Good product, indulgent, with Rowan Atkinson levels of packaging when you buy it in store.
Spending time with friends. Buying little treats like a piece of fun make up of hair clip. Upgrade to usual hair care products. Little things that makes things a bit more enjoyable without taking extra time.
For the busiest times, grocery delivery, pre prepped food (there are people who will do your shopping and deliver it prepped so carrots are cut etc).
Throw out clutter to help with a calm environment.
Literally taking a deep breath with yoga/walks/jogs/music/anything that requires deep breaths.
Tv night: 1x week make popcorn on the stove or throw in a frozen pizza and watch 1 episode from 2 tv shows on my watch list.
one episode from 2 or 3 shows once a week means you get the tv/movie night feeling without binging, but still have something to look forward to the next week.
Treat yourself to a dishy romance or mystery novel. Paperback! Inexpensive!
Also, spend extra time on caring for your body, like a luxurious warm shower, ice rolling your face while your coffee brews, doing your skincare by candlelight etc.
I posted above about my job woes and just took an hour over lunch to treat myself a bit. I picked up a ready made meal at the high end deli (still healthy and much less than Uber/Door Dash), grabbed a small sweet treat with it and a fancy seltzer, browsed the library on my way back and scored a new release that I had on my libby hold. I then walked slooooowly along the nature path by my house and enjoyed the leaves and the trees. It helped, a lot and reminded me I should (and can) do this more often, for under $25.
Take a morning off of work and sleep in, drink my coffee, and tackle dumb chores like dry cleaning or package returns. Today I stopped into a homegoods to look at the Christmas knickknacks—I didn’t buy anything but it scratched an itch.
What did you major in in college and why? Do you think it was a good decision long term?
I was talking with some friends whose kids are choosing college majors. Honestly I don’t think it makes a huge difference in the long term given how different peoples careers tend to be, but it is good for kids to keep in mind both their interests and the career options.
I majored in econ, which I liked because I liked math and practical math a lot. I think its been a good basis for how to think about to things and to learn new things.
engineering major and 100% yes. the logic and problem-solving aspects were a great basis for my entirely-unrelated career.
+1
Agree, except math major. Teaches you to think and communicate.
Sociology, don’t regret it one bit. I learned critical thinking and analysis skills, while I don’t work in the field, my degree is mandatory for the job I ended up with. Earn six figures doing good and I’m happy with it.
I majored in management after a brief foray into theater arts. Honestly I feel like the theater has been more useful over the years. I still laugh about the “Management Information Systems” class I took ca. 1980 about mainframes vs. desktop workstations. And they were also very high on Japanese “just in time” delivery systems…
I majored in dance, and I got so much out of it! Discipline, teamwork, resilience, tenacity, a strong sense of composition, the ability to learn new skills quickly. The arts are amazing, even if you don’t spend your whole career there.
I do sometimes think about how my pathway would look now vs when I graduated in the 90s. I was able to find a cheap, rent-stabilized apartment in a safe neighborhood, so I could dance for little to no pay and live on barista and waitress jobs. That’s just so much harder now. And the cost of a college degree is so astronomical that of course everyone is trying to a cost-benefit analysis before committing to it. I wish there were easy solutions, but I don’t see them.
I have a performing arts bachelor’s degree, and it set me up to start performing again on an amateur basis 20 years after I graduated and quit to get a “real” job with health insurance.
I think the job market has changed a lot since we graduated. Now you have to show that you’re super specialized in whatever employer’s niche if you even want a chance of being looked at. IMO that means for kids these days, they’d better choose imminently employable majors; no faffing around in some interesting corner of the liberal arts, etc.
It’s hard to guess this though, as a lot of computer science majors are finding out. I think majoring in something you dislike because its employable is not a good idea, and a lot of people are in this position.
Like Anon @ 12:38 said I actually lean towards majoring in something that is a good general baseline, like engineering. An engineering major is well respected in a range of fields because of how it teaches you to think.
I think economics and then my masters were the equivalent of that for me. I don’t know what other majors work. Maybe philosophy, depending on the school?
IMO philosophy is the first thing people think of as a useless, unemployable major. Philosophy will usually hurt you when someone sees it on your resume. At best it can be a minor paired with a marketable major (accounting, econ, engineering)
Is this just your gut feeling? I thought philosophy majors competed pretty well with econ majors.
I think that philosophy telegraphs “educated person” to someone like-minded (various SLAC professors, classics majors). But it telegraphs absolutely nothing to the bots who run things now.
Signed,
Philosophy major
I had to take courses in critical theory and political theory for my non-philosophy bachelor’s and master’s degrees, and both have been surprisingly useful in my unrelated career and in my life as a reader and educated citizen. As a hiring manager, I’d count a philosophy degree as a definite positive in deciding whether to interview someone (of course they’d have to show some evidence of technical skills and subject matter expertise for the job too).
If people are setting their bots to exclude philosophy, I have a lot less sympathy with their complaints about new hires!
English and philosophy double major here, a “hurt” that I compounded with a PhD in literary history. I went into book publishing, and then into communications. Now I lead a specialized communications team in higher ed and make six figures.
My education taught me high-level analytical and research skills, and the PhD in particular gives me street cred at a university. I probably would have made more money with my skills outside higher ed, but it’s been a great career, and my work area directly supports causes I care about, including international collaboration and meaningful research.
I still err towards hiring people with engineering undergrad and whatever masters they wanted to do. Engineering teaches logical and systems thinking, and seems to produce patient people who can sit with a problem and seek to understand it and work on it.
Of course there are a wide range of engineering disciplines, and the student needs a sufficient level of competence to be admitted and then do well.
Music undergrad, computer science masters. Whatever major keeps a student’s interest and allows them to finish with a degree is perfectly ok in my book.
I am the technical person who can get up and talk to large groups. It’s just performance by a different name. Music worked well for me but I definitely burned out on doing the music that paid the bills vs what interested me. For me, doing it for a living ruined the passion I had. My 2nd degree is something I’m good at, and don’t hate, but I’m not passionate about.
I went to a fairly selective SLAC and in the long term it didn’t matter too much. I double major in English and biology and did all the work so that they could be premed which I never ended up wanting to do. My major did help me land my first job which helped me pay for grad school (I worked at a big university). Years later, the work I did it. The first job got me the first job and what would ultimately be my career through a coincidence-the work was entirely unrelated, but the person that ran the study I worked on lived next-door or one did PTA stuff with the hiring manager for the job in the other career. That got me in my interview.
I think it’s important to choose a major that teaches you to read, write, think, and solve problems. Knowing the basics of a broad career field or subject such as engineering, math, or econ is also useful.
I would discourage my child from pursuing one of those majors that are pitched as career-focused but are actually extremely generic and don’t teach either critical thinking or practical skills–communications, business, etc. I see friends’ kids with these degrees struggling to articulate career goals and find jobs. I would also discourage social science majors that don’t teach rigorous quantitative methodology (e.g., sociology).
I have a bachelor’s degree in music performance and English, plus a master’s in public policy and a law degree. I use them all on a daily basis. The only one I regret is the law degree; I would have been much happier and have been less limited in my career if I’d opted for a Ph.D. in econ instead.
I agree with the eng/math/econ. You get a good education and can decide how to use it. I’m trying to think of what the equivalent degrees are for a kid who is not math-inclined.
I wouldn’t push my child to major in anything specific but I would definitely encourage a more general degree rather than a hyper-specific one.
Classics.
I majored in mechanical engineering and have been a working engineer in the auto industry for the last decade. I also have a masters in the same subject that was paid for by the companies I’ve worked for.
I was interested in science and was on the robotics team in high school, did well enough in college and did extracurriculars that got me noticed by auto companies (they didn’t usually recruit at my school) and have been here ever since.
My role is a combination of project management and engineering, heavy on the project management. I’m overall happy with it and am proud that I am here doing this work.
I think the choice of major does have less import than we like to believe, but it’s still possible for students to really make their lives difficult.
The two big mistakes I’ve seen are people who major in the degree that doesn’t let them enter the career they think it will and students who either design their own major or pick a watered-down major. One woman I know would like to be teacher in public schools, but majored in child psychology (or something like that) and will need to pick up the master’s degree at some point. It’s been a huge source of frustration for her. She’s not alone though, because we get resumes all the time with majors like Environmental Policy, but where the student didn’t have to take the intro sequences to biology or chemistry, or Data Science, but where the student didn’t have to learn to code or take any statistics. Basically the college created a major similar to an existing one, but without the substance. I don’t know what happens to those grads.
Don’t all teachers need to get a masters degree?
Not at all, but the pay structures and continuing ed requirements heavily preference it. It’s led to the proliferation of online, box-checking, fairly pointless master’s degrees whose sole worth is moving to the right on the payscale. Nothing wrong with doing what you gotta do to make a living in a low paying profession, but it’s pretty soul sucking.
I have a kid in public school, only one of her elementary school teachers so far has had a master’s degree. It doesn’t seem common, at least not where we live. That teacher’s master’s degree was in gifted education and it was very significant and did not feel like box-checking at all. My daughter has had a lot of good teachers but that teacher was on a different level in terms of her ability to understand and challenge high ability kids.
I think master’s degrees are more common for private schools. My husband went to private school and pretty much all his teachers had subject master’s degrees (or even PhDs).
In my state, for public school teachers a check-the-box master’s in education is very common. For private secondary school teachers a master’s or doctorate in the subject, not education, is typical.
Agree that its better to major in the “umbrella” topic, like chemistry, rather than environmental science.
Accounting. Excellent choice.
I went to one if the jesuit schools and it was a perfect choice for me – smaller campus and class sizes, strong B school, strong ethics emphasis, and liberal arts.
I figured out I wanted to do accounting in high school.
There a strong pipeline or well established stream to follow into fulltime work after graduation for undergrads. And you dont have to do just one thing, plenty of overlap and opportunity to leap frog to other business roles.
Pick the major you get the best grades in. Fads with majors come and go but GPA is pretty consistently important.
Music and biology undergrad degrees. I went to med school, of course.
Yes, it was an excellent decision. They love diversity of backgrounds in medicine, and my music degree came up in many interviews.
Got my bachelor’s in physics, then went to law school, since age 30 have done something unrelated to both physics and law. I think the degree has served me pretty well. It impressed law schools (since it’s a unique background for a lawyer) and probably helped me get merit scholarships, and my law school merit scholarship had a huge financial impact on our lives. However, I didn’t actually like physics and a big part of me wishes I had studied something I actually enjoyed. I felt pressure from my parents to go into a hard science, but I knew by high school I didn’t actually want to be a scientist. If I’d listened to that voice inside my head earlier I might have gotten a degree in a field I actually wanted to continue it. But overall my life turned out well and I don’t have major complaints.
Political science. I thought I wanted to work in politics, which I did for a brief period after law school, before deciding I didn’t like DC or politics enough to stay there. I’m a generic litigator now. It’s fine. If I was doing it over, though, I’d probably go with a science degree of some sort. I was actually very good at biology and probably should have stuck with that (I was premed for a while until it became very clear I did not like people enough to become a doctor. I think I would have really liked to do something related to genetics research, though).
Latin. It was my easiest subject. Now I work with numbers, and frankly I think Latin is a very good subject for the field.
English, which has served me extremely well as a lawyer. Critical thinking, close reading of difficult texts and effective writing are important for English majors and lawyers alike.
Any advice that I can pass on? My son finished grad school in a niche engineering field, worked for one year then got a fabulous job with a big company in our home state that values work/life balance (9-5 and childcare on site). His gf (intended fiance) is finishing grad school in the same niche field and applied for entry level position in home state. She was offered a big salary in another state at a not so stable company. Her family is in home state as well. It seems the best option is to take the job and they are long distance for another year. If I were her mom, I would remind her that she isn’t engaged. I am not in a high tech field so I don’t know how bad it would be if she bailed on the great offer should she get the gig she wants.
I think you should let the adults figure it out.
agree with this, but managing two careers is hard, especially in this day and age
+1. It’s not your place to weigh in on this woman’s career path, especially when you aren’t familiar with the industry. Your adult son can decide whether he’d rather move out of state, try long distance, or break up. Stay out of it unless he asks for advice.
He asked. That was implicit in my question. I am not advising her but I do know that she has her own decisions to make. Unless you can respond to what I asked, then stop.
I was still asking my mom for relationship and career advice well into adulthood. He asked.
I think if you say anything it will sound like you have some insider knowledge that your son isn’t that committed to her!
They were waiting until both finished school. I was thinking that if they were actually engaged, his employer might be more committed to boosting her in the interview process. That may not be true though.
I don’t think this is a thing, unless they’re in academia maybe?
At least, I’m in tech and it’s not a thing I’ve ever encountered, so if that’s what they’re asking for about, I think it’s a no
On the question about whether it’s a bad idea to renege on an accepted offer if she gets the one she really wants, there’s still some risk, but it’s a lot more acceptable in many tech fields now than it was 10 years ago. I’m guessing this is something like a new grad offer now for a start date summer or fall 2027 – if she’s actually starting the job now and worried about potentially resigning for a new offer in fall 2027 ie after ~9 months, in most tech fields, that’s not gonna be a negative for her reputation at all.
Thanks, Anecdata. Start early 2027 but her mentor didn’t think it would be the worst bridge to burn.
yeah have never heard of any kind of spousal accommodation/preference, outside of academia.
That’s not a thing.
I would tell my son that he should be supportive of whatever decision she makes. Don’t pressure her to come home just because you’re sick of LD. One more year is nothing in the grand scheme of things. And, you don’t want to start your life together with resentment already picking away at your relationship.
If she asked, I would tell her to go where she feels she can get the best experience. I would caution her to not get used to the big salary, if that’s what she chooses, because it’ll make it harder to leave what she already knows is a not great company.
Thank you. The truth is he is ready to settle down and she is more focused on her career. She also has an Ivy degree so she has options. She facetimed me today and told me she is negotiating for more remote days and PTO. I think it will work out but its hard for couples. Went through this myself when my bf-now husband was a long distance contract worker. Eventually took less money to be home.
Stay out of it, ffs.
Aw. anon at 4:10. The facetimed me today and asked me what I thought. I am sorry you have a bad relationship with either your parents or children or both. My family talks with one another.
does anyone on here work in apparel or product design? I really don’t understand how in this day and age so many companies get things wrong – we celebrate Hanukkah and the amount of incorrect merchandise on the market is truly astounding to me. Old Navy had to pull their PJs for this year bc they had something on them completely unrelated to the holiday.
Oh is that why Old Navy doesn’t have Hanukkah Pjs this year? I was wondering!
Have you seen hanukkahfails on IG? It’s an account dedicated to parodying all the ridiculous things they put on Hanukkah items.
yes, their PJs had hamantaschen on them. i truly dont understand why this is that hard
They probably had AI design the print.
Yea, that was my first thought.
At this point, even AI knows better than this. Also this (non-Hanukkah items on Hanukkah clothing) has been an issue since at least the 90s, long before AI was on anyone’s radar.
Oh man! It’s ridiculous how little attention they pay to it.
I live in New Mexico, and I HATE when out-of-state marketers put saguaro cacti on New Mexico-related things. New Mexico does NOT have saguaros. We have plenty of cacti, but not saguaros. Saguaros are an Arizona thing.
That’s infuriating! I speak French and there is a lot of apparel with awkwardly phrased or straight-up incorrect French on it.
I agree with the rec for museum shops and would also look at local artisan shops or crafts fair. The piece of jewelry I get the most compliments on is a small-ish jasper pendant (maybe 1″ x 1.5″) that I got from a booth at a festival. I have several pendants that I wear on a plain silver chain, as well as some chunkier (but not huge) bead and stone pieces. The one in most regular rotation at the moment is a simplified representation of the molecular structure of serotonin; I bought it from a local maker in San Juan, PR who does not seem to have a website, but I think you can find the on Etsy and elsewhere.
I rely on necklace extenders to change the length of a necklace to work with different necklines.