Beauty Empties: Which Products Do You Actually Finish and Then Buy Again?
This post may contain affiliate links and Corporette® may earn commissions for purchases made through links in this post. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Ladies, what beauty products do you use so often that you get “empties,” where you actually get to the bottom of the lipstick or jar, and what do you buy again and again?
I tend to rotate among so many different products that I almost never get to the bottom of anything, let alone say “I definitely need THAT again, right this instant.”
Still, even I have my regular items that I buy again and again, so I thought I'd round up my beauty empties. Hopefully everyone will share their own lists!
Update: There were so many great comments from readers on things they loved (that were new to me) we decided to put them into the post also, both for ease of browsing as well as easy linking when there's a big sale afoot or you're trying to make the most of a Triple Points day… :)
I also did a few reviews of things I'd bought after reading readers' recommendations, including Sunday Riley Good Genes, The Ordinary's caffeine solution, and more…
Beauty Products I've Bought Again and Again
Skincare Products I've Bought Again and Again
2025 Update: Here's my latest skincare routine! I use a peptide serum, then Vitamin C, then my moisturizer, then sunscreen. (I save my prescription tretinoin for before bed.) I also occasionally use this BHA, this overnight mask, this 20-minute mask, and this 1-5 minute mask. (Never all at once!) When my skin is feeling especially dry I do like this snail essence paired with this crazy rich cream.
- Bioelements' Sleepwear face cream (I wrote about it here.): [Amazon]
- Bioelements' Really Rich Moisture: [Amazon]
- Neutrogena Cream Eye Makeup Remover: [Amazon] [Ulta] (discontinued, here's my new favorite)
- Caudalíe Lip Conditioner (I wrote about it here.): [Sephora] [Amazon] [Nordstrom]
- Sunday Riley Good Genes (about to buy my 3rd! — here's my review) [Nordstrom]
- Drunk Elephant Baby Facial (about to buy my 3rd! — here's my review) [Sephora]
- Sunscreen – Missha Sun Milk (here's my review): [Amazon] (I and the readers used to love Biore Watery Essence but I think they updated the formula in the past few years and not for the best — readers, what are your thoughts? Update: here's my latest favorite sunscreen)
- Neosporin Lip Health Overnight Renewal Therapy (I wrote about it here and here.): [Amazon]
- Prescription retinoid (I wrote about my skincare routine here.)
- Vitamin C serum — I've had multiple empties of Mad Hippie but now I'm using Obaji's 10% Vitamin C. [Amazon]
- Curél Daily Healing Original Lotion for general hands/legs/elbows/ anywhere else that needs moisture [Amazon]
- Honorable Mentions
- When I was younger and had oilier skin, I loved Queen Helene's Mint Julep Mask. [Amazon]
- We've bought numerous cartons of CeraVe lotion for my kids' sensitive skin: CeraVe Moisturizing Cream Daily Face and Body Moisturizer for Dry Skin. [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Just bought this for my mother and she was raving about it so I might try it for myself: Hard as Hoof Nail Strengthening Creme [Amazon]
Hair Products I've Bought Again and Again
Psst: As of 2024, these are some of Kat's favorite hair products (she largely follows curly hair routines)… but she loves this $30 brush/blowdryer!
(I'm probably somewhere between 2C/3A wavy/curly right now, but I'm more interested in avoiding sulfates because of the keratin treatments I've started getting.)
- 2021 update: Alterna Caviar Anti-Aging [Sephora] (here's my review)
- Giovanni Deep Moisture Shampoo & Conditioner: [Amazon]
- Not Your Mother's Beach Babe Coconut Conditioner: [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Palmer's Olive Oil Formula W/Vitamin E Condition Replenish: [Amazon]
Makeup I've Actually Used to the Bottom and Then Bought More
- Primers/foundational type products that you put on first:
- MAC’s Prep + Prime (I wrote about it here.): [Amazon] [Nordstrom] [Ulta]
- e.l.f. Lip Lock Pencil (I wrote about it here.): [Amazon]
- Urban Decay Original Eyeshadow Primer Potion: [Sephora] [Amazon] [Nordstrom] [Ulta]
- Bare Minerals Original Foundation SPF 15 (I barely use it but I believe I'm on my second container.): [Sephora] [Amazon [Ulta]
- this is my latest favorite foundation
- Cheeks: NARS blush (in Orgasm) (I wrote about it here.): [Sephora] [Amazon] [Nordstrom] [Ulta]
- Eyes: L'Oreal Voluminous Original Mascara (I still buy it but I'm more likely to use other mascaras most days; haven't finished and rebought anything else though.): [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Lips:
- Clinique Chubby stick in Fuller Fig: [Sephora] [Amazon][Ulta]
- Clinique's Black Honey (I wrote about it here in this massive crazy post on tinted lip balms.) [Sephora] [Amazon] [Nordstrom] [Ulta]
- Honorable mention: I got to the bottom of my NARS Canaille (um, possibly 8 years after I bought it, yes) and was super excited to go buy a second tube and then realized — waah — it was a limited edition color. Grumble. (I know Wardrobe Oxygen sings the praises of Pigalle but I'm meh on the tube I bought on her recommendation.): [Sephora] [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Honorable mention: When I was younger I bought MAC's Odyssey over and over and over again. A few months ago I wondered why the heck I stopped, so I bought it again. It's fine. I probably won't get to the bottom of it, but I can't quite put my finger on why I don't love it as much as I used to. [Nordstrom] [Amazon] [Ulta]
Those are mine — which are your beauty empties, readers?
As of 2024, my short makeup routine is pretty boring — curled eyelashes + concealer + blush (Nars Orgasm) + powder, with a different lipstick and eyeliner depending on my mood. If I'm feeling extra fancy I'll add mascara, highlighter, and/or do my brows with this cream and a brush similar to this one (here's my review). (I also add eye shadows in the “extra” days but it's a huge variety, maybe 25 or so different ones.)
Some favorite lipsticks include Clinique (Graped Up), NARS lipstick (Damage), Fenty (Goji Gang), NARS gloss (Orgasm, Fast Lane), and Clinique (Black Honey). I use this NYX lipliner (Natural) for almost all of them.
My favorite eyeliners as of 2024: Chanel (Espresso), Urban Decay (Sabbath, Smoke), and Clinique (Intense Chocolate & Plum). I also really like NYX and Sephora's eyeliners.
Office Makeup: Beauty Favorites from the Corporette Readers
Skincare Rec'd By Readers (see full comments below):
- Elta MD Sunscreen: [Amazon]
- Dr. Jart Cicapair Color Correcting Treatment: [Sephora] [Amazon]
- Origins GinZing Eye Cream: [Sephora] [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Paula's Choice 2% BHA Liquid: [Amazon]
- Queen Helene Mint Julep Mask: [Amazon]
- Simple Skin Facial Wipes: [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Sunday Riley Good Genes: [Sephora] [Nordstrom]
Makeup Rec'd By Readers (see full comments below):
- Benefit Boi-ing Industrial Strength Concealer: [Sephora] [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Bioderma Sensibo H20 Micellar Water: [Amazon]
- Burt's Bees Lip Balm: [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Clinique Quickliner: [Sephora] [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Covergirl Eyeliner Pencils: [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Covergirl LashBlast Volume Mascara: [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Dior Dior Addict Lip Glow: [Sephora] [Amazon] [Nordstrom]
- Dior Diorshow Mascara: [Sephora] [Amazon]
- Dr. Jart BB Cream: [Sephora] [Amazon]
- Fresh Sugar Lip Treatment: [Sephora] [Amazon]
- Garnier Micellar Water: [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Glossier Boy Brow: [Amazon]
- Laura Mercier Bronzer: [Sephora] [Amazon]
- Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer: [Sephora] [Amazon]
- L'Oreal Voluminous Mascara: [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Concealer: [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Makeup: [Amazon] [Ulta]
- Rosebud Perfume Co. Smith's Rosebud Salve: [Sephora] [Amazon]
- Urban Decay Primer Potion: [Sephora] [Amazon] [Ulta]
Hair Products Rec'd By Readers (see full comments below):
This post was originally written Oct. 2017, but updated in April 2021 to reopen comments.
These are my go-to products for my pink, fair, combination skin:
– Laura Mercier silk creme photo edition moisturizing foundation (nicely sheer, but can build to full coverage if you want it)
– Clinique chubby in the nude foundation stick (nice for more coverage)
– Laura Mercier bronzer
yaaaaasss Laura Mercier! i use the tinted moisturizer with sunblock almost every morning, and it makes a great foundation when i’m doing heavier coverage at events. i’m terrified they’re going to do away with my color, so i buy multiple tubes every time i run out haha
Origins GinZing eye cream
Cetaphil face wash
DiorGlow Lip Glow 001 – somewhere between balm and lipstick, natural and (seemingly) universally flattering, I basically wear this every day. It’s the only lip product I’ve gotten 4+ times and am ordering again today
I used to buy Bobby Brown BB cream but have recently switched to Marcelle City tinted cream – it’s half the price and I feel like it makes my skin look better but more natural.
Everything else – mascara, blush, shadow, moisturizer – I have a rotating mix that I like but nothing I am super loyal to.
Lip Glow is a dream.
Love this topic!
My #1 is Marcelle New∙Age Precision 8-in-1 Power Serum. Love this stuff.
Face cream: I can’t be trusted to wear SPF everyday, and rarely wear makeup, so I always have Lancome Bienfait Multi-Vital SPF 30 and wear it daily (unless I am actually wearing makeup). In winter, it is not quite enough for my dry skin, but I add a drop of oil and it works fine.
Buffy body bar from Lush: I have been using this for at least 15 years. Eliminates the need for body lotion in the summer, works great under body lotion in the winter when I’m super dry.
MAC Prep and Prime: This stuff changed my (lipstick) life and I will be using it forever.
Burt’s Bees original beeswax lip balm: Can’t live without it.
Oh! And Liz Earle face wash with the muslin cloths – started using this about 4-5 years ago thanks to Birchbox, and I love it.
I’m impressed you get to the bottom of a thing of lip balm without losing it first. I’m forever buying more just because I lost it!
My trick (?) is having multiples, and always in the same places. Currently I have a Burts Bee’s lip balm in: the zippered pocket of my purse, my nightstand, my monitor stand at work, and the diaper bag.
Skincare:
Clinique Dramatically Different gel moisturizer
Clinique mild cleanser (for PM)
Cerave cleanser (for AM)
Dermalogica Skin Smoothing Cream
Neutrogena makeup remover
Vaseline lip care
Burt’s Bees lip balm in coconut lime
Makeup:
Stila Kitten (eyeshadow)
Urban Decay Naked foundation
Urban Decay primer potion (eyes)
Clinique quickliner (eyeliner)
Loreal Infallible lipgloss in sangria
Hair:
Aquage uplifting foam
Bed Head manipulator
Paul Mitchell skinny serum
Redken shampoo/conditioner
+1 to Urban Decay Primer Potion and Clinique Quickliner. I have bought the primer potion for a couple years now (and I’ve tried plenty of other eye primers too – this is the best). I’ve probably bought Quickliner for at least 5 years in a row – maybe more like a decade. I like the black/brown shade best. I have sensitive eyes/skin too – both of these products work great for me.
Also agree with the Redken vote, but haven’t bought it recently as I’m trying to get by with less expensive products.
Whoa! We are like product twins.
Face:
Ponds Cold Cream
Fresh Soy Face Cleanser
Perfume:
La Vie Est Belle – Lancome
Hair:
Tresemme Tre Two Extra Hold Hairspray
Lips:
Rosebud Perfume Co Smith’s Lip Balm (original and minted rose – I have these scattered all over my apt and office)
Buxom full-on lip polish in Claire
Eyes:
Maybelline Falsies mascara in blackest black
Yeah, I do a lot of product hopping. A few I do regularly rebuy:
Lipstick Queen Medieval (bright but sheer, easy to apply, not too glossy or shiny, never “too much” color)
Julep Love Your Bare Face Detoxifying Cleansing Stick (gentle enough for my skin, which can have trouble with some cleansers, but still feels like it really gets things clean)–I keep a membership to their site just for this, and skip deliveries on the months when I don’t need more cleanser
Murad Rapid Age Spot And Pigment Lightening Serum (for a few pregnancy-darkened spots and surgical scars–I use this as a spot treatment, not everywhere)
CeraVe facial cleansers (after years of monogamy with Cetaphil)
Bioderma Sensibio H2O (seriously, the best)
Soap & Glory body washes
EltaMD UV Physical Broad Spectrum SPF 41 Sunscreen (The only sunscreen that I’ve found that moisturizes my face all day without burning my eyes)
BECCA Backlight Priming Filter and First Light Priming Filter. LOVE.
MAC Prep and Prime Fix+
Original beautyblenders and the Real Technique’s version
+1 to EltaMD. GREAT product.
I’m always so surprised by how many people love this sunscreen – it just does not work for me. I keep trying, but it always feels too runny and I feel like I end up tasting it?
A question: I’m trying to build a good skincare regime, and am having a hard time finding articles on what exactly I should be doing.
I think someone here recommended beautypedia and reddit’s skin care page…but neither really had what I’m looking for: a basic, here’s what to do to treat your skin well. I’m 28, have fairly normal skin, but am acne-prone. Looking to create a sustainable routine that I can keep up.
I just started using an BHA product (Paula’s Choice, skin perfecting 2% BHA liquid), but would like to add on to my skin routine both to treat the acne and make sure I’m preventing wrinkles. Any advice?
If you’re starting from scratch, the most important change you can make right now is to wear sunscreen every single day. I like physical sunscreens (made with lots of zinc) rather than chemical ones, but it’s totally up to you–the important thing is that it’s something you’ll be willing to wear every day.
Consider adding a retinol or retinoid at night–this will help prevent wrinkles and also can keep acne at bay. I’ve been using the 2% retinoid from The Ordinary after a recommendation here; the price is right (<$10) and I definitely saw quick results with acne. (I'm 30, so not a lot of wrinkles to treat right now, but my derm strongly recommends the retinoid now anyway as a preventative measure.) Note that the retinoid, like the BHA, will make your skin more sun-sensitive, so again: sunscreen!
I think I'm a little further along than you in trying to build a good regime, but I still feel rather overwhelmed by the volume of recommendations and options available. Sometimes sticking to the basics is easier!
+1, sunscreen and retinol. The retinol will help both wrinkles and acne, but you MUST wear sunscreen.
CeraVe’s retinol serum is really gentle and affordable. You can also get Differin over the counter now, although it’s much stronger and I’ve heard about people having reactions to it.
Try this article as a good place to start: https://intothegloss.com/2017/05/essential-skin-care-routine/
Everyone recommends wearing sunscreen every day. Why?? I am almost never in the sun on a day-to-day basis. I drive to work, go inside, work all day, and then drive home after dark. I am maybe in the sun 5-10 min to walk and grab lunch but that’s it. I don’t see why I need sunscreen on an average workday. I totally understand if it’s the weekend and I’m going to be out and about, though.
You are exposed to damaging rays through most windows, including those in your car (likely not your windshield). A few years ago, the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology published a study indicating that a majority of skin cancer tumors were found on the left side of the bodies and faces of people who drive a lot: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/05/health/05really.html
Eh – what is “a lot” are we talking about professional drivers (semi-trucks, etc.) or people with long communtes (1 hr+).
I clicked through to the study and it doesn’t say. But it does define “majority” here to mean 52% (left) vs 48% (right), so I’d call that a bare majority. And it was a stronger trend in men, than women. Statistically significant, sure, but not spectacularly compelling, in my book.
And it was a retrospective review of skin cancer patients – So, you’re only looking at people who have already been identified as having cancer and looking at whether they have lesions on right or left side, (right? I could only read the abstract, maybe the article has more detail).
I’d fine the study where you look at truck drivers driving a certain number of hours a day and THEN look at the rate of incidence of right vs left side tumors way more compelling.
I think the going wisdom is “you can get sun damage through the car window, you can get sun damage during the five minute walk to the office, and you can get sun damage even when it’s cloudy,” BUT I honestly kind of agree with you and wouldn’t push somebody with your schedule on this issue.
+1 I have a similar schedule and I don’t wear sunscreen unless I plan to be outside for an extended period of time (like the beach/lake). I just can’t get that worked up about the amount of sun exposure I’m getting.
I spent yesterday at the Melanoma clinic at the UCSF Cancer Center, surrounded by people who could not get that worked up about their sun exposure. While no cancer is completely preventable, think of melanoma in the same way that you think of lung cancer. You can prevent most melanomas with a topical cream and avoiding the sun, just like you can prevent most lung cancers by avoiding smoke. Melanoma can be disfiguring (happy to share photos of my leg as exhibit A, but trust me, you can skip it and just envision an angry, five inch scar, then imagine it on you face). Worse yet, metastatic melanoma kills and kills quickly. Daily, minimal exposure adds up. Please, please for those of you dismissing sunscreen on this chat — think about this more carefully. You never, ever want to think to yourself — as I do — I have cancer AND IT IS MY FAULT. As an added bonus, sunscreen helps protect against wrinkles!
I agree, but my derm told me that there are UV rays in fluorescent office lighting, so that convinced me.
The sunscreen thing also depends on your skin type, too, and where you live.
I have very light Nordic skin and can get sun burnt on a cloudy day. I have been sun burnt through a car window. I still try and remember not to use sunscreen every day during the darkest part of the winter to be able to get a little vitamin D, but I can get sun burnt during winter as well, so I add vitamin D supplements.
I do sometimes feel like the skin damage “canary”. On me, the sun damage is instantly visible, on everybody else the danger is silent and sneaky.
Why not go with one of Paula’s kits? I think her products are generally very good and fairly reasonably priced. I have slightly oily skin (was acne prone when I was younger, not so much now at 41) and love this sunscreen of hers: RESIST Super-Light Wrinkle Defense SPF 30. I do that and the 2% BHA during the day. I use CeraVe cleanser or simple face wipes, and try to remember to put on Paula’s Antioxident serum at night. When my skin gets dryer in the winter I use her RESIST Anti-Aging Clear Skin hydrator at night to moisturize.
I disagree that you need retinol – BHA is serving the same function and is more appropriate for oily skin.
I love Caroline Hirons. She has a number of cheat sheets that you should be able to piece something together. https://www.carolinehirons.com/2016/10/cheat-sheets-are-back.html
I rebuy my skincare products regularly because I don’t really deviate from my routine. But in terms of makeup, I love trying new things, but I always rebuy Nars concealer, Smashbox CC cream, and Diorshow mascara.
Oh and Burt’s Bees lip balm – and yes I use them up! I keep one with my everywhere.
I keep this everywhere too but they make my lips peel something terrible!
For my oily, acne prone skin, these are my favs —
Skincare:
Neutrogena Oil Free Acne Wash
Clean & Clear® Dual Action Moisturizer Oil Free
RoC Retinol Correxion Eye Cream
Clean and Clear Oil Absorbing Sheets
Kirkland makeup removing wipes
Makeup:
Bare Minerals Complexion Rescue Tinted Hydrating Gel Cream Broad Spectrum SPF 30 (less coverage)
Clinique Acne Solutions Liquid Makeup (more coverage)
Clinique Stay Matte Sheer Pressed Powder
Clinique All About Eyes Concealer
Eyes:
CLINIQUE All About Shadow 8-Pan Palette
Almay Intense i-Color™ Eyeliner (it soft and smudges well, but could last longer)
MAYBELLINE Full ‘N Soft Mascara
Clinique quickliner (doesn’t smudge as well but lasts longer)
Cheeks:
Clinique cheek pop (blush)
TARTE Amazonian Clay 12-Hour Blush
Face:
– cetaphil
-granier micellar water for makeup remover. this has made a huge difference in my skin
-Olay Complete All Day Moisturizer with Broad Spectrum SPF 30 – best drug store sunscreen for my skin with SPF 30
Makeup:
– covergirl lashblast
– maybelline skin clearing BB cream
– kat von d liquid eyeliner in tattoo – best liquid eyeliner
– burts bees lipstick in ruby ripple – perfect color red for my coloring (dark hair/light skin), is creamy and wears off very evenly leaving a hint of stain if I forget to reapply
-boing boing concealer
Hair:
-L’Oreal Excellence Creme Triple Protection Hair Color for coloring my hair at home (go to a salon to get it dyed twice to keep the color consistent/richer) but color my roots at home every four weeks
How do you use the miceller water – with a cotton ball?
Yes, or little cotton pads if you prefer.
Fresh Sugar original lip balm. It’s ridiculously expensive for lip balm, but I love it so much.
– Cerave PM moisturizer (use it in AM and PM)
– Clinique Even Better foundation
– DiorShow Iconic mascara
Most everything else is I would be willing to try something else, but nothing will replace these 3 for me and my finicky sensitive skin.
Ride or die repurchase items for my very dry, redness-prone skin:
— Aquaphor and CeraVe ointment. I have little tubes everywhere for dry spots.
— Bioderma micellar water
— Glossier priming moisturizer (regular in the summer, rich in the winter)
— Cicapair color corrector (and I just bought the serum to go with it! I like it so far.)
Makeup:
— Blinc mascara
— Laura Mercier tinted moisturizer
— Glossier boy brow
Hair: Tea Tree Tingle, forever and ever and ever.
Cicapair! I am obsessed with that stuff.
Dr Jarts BB cream (or is it CC, can’t remember)
Skincare:
Origins GinZing eye cream (a must every morning to get rid of puffiness)
Shiseido undereye SPF (yes really!)
Makeup:
Maybelline Age Rewind undereye concealer
Neutrogena Healthy Skin Anti-Aging Perfector (more than a BB cream, less than a foundation)
Hair:
Marc Anthony Curl Envy Perfect Curl Styling Cream (a random, amazing find at my CVS – SO good for air drying wavy hair!)
I’m surprised no one has mentioned Rodan + Fields. To be very clear, I am NOT a consultant for them and I never intend to be. But their products have changed my skin incredibly. I use the entire Redefine line which is for the reduction of fine lines, pores and loss of firmness. I also use their microdermabrasion paste to help with KP on my arms and their Lash Boost to help regrow my lashes.
There are plenty of wonderful products that are not sold by MLMs. MLMs are incredibly predatory and harm women disproportionately.
+1. Also I looked at their prices and their stuff is crazy expensive!
I also have KP and I would say that I’ve found tremendous success with a Korean/Japanese exfoliating towel (Italian towels, scrubby mits, whatever) alone OR with salicylic acid wash (dandruff shampoo is cheapest I find) to get both the chemical and physical exfoliation. I’ll sometimes also then use a stridex wipe (again, more gentle chemical exfoliation) and then use a lotion on top of that. Cheap, effective, and no MLM needed.
I basically buy the entire lines of Yes To and Burts Bees – and just switch between products as the seasons change. My only reliable – can’t-leave-the-house-without-it is the Yes to Carrots moisturizer and sunscreen because it doesn’t feel like anything when you wear it, and I’m super pale. I also use Bare Escentuals eye shadows and mascara because they were well-rated on the Environmental Working Group database.
My new obsession is Sunday Riley Good Genes. It is transformative. I’ve used other acid products for years and scoffed at the idea of spending so much money on something that had the same active ingredients as a generic, but this stuff really makes a visible instant difference. I’m kind of obsessed.
Other ride or die products:
Boing concealer
Cicapair redness correction cream
Revlon color-stay eyeliner
Obaji hydroquinone and retinol products
seconding – I had never spent more than like, $40 on a skincare product (and only for a huge bottle of something I already knew I liked), but I received a sample of Sunday Riley Good Genes and was BLOWN AWAY by the difference in my combination, hormonal acne-prone skin. I purchased a full size immediately and have repurchased twice since then.
Skincare:
-Glossier milky jelly cleanser – I honestly don’t know that this stuff is any better than anything else, but for some reason I really love it
-Retin-A – I actually have two different strengths that I alternate between if my skin gets angry
-Nivea Daily Essentials moisturizer with SPF – I know Nivea is kind of problematic at the moment but this stuff is great and I love the way it smells. Haven’t found a holy grail evening moisturizer – right now I’m using a sample of 111skin anti-aging cream, which is great but I’m not planning on dropping $270 for a full jar.
Makeup:
-Almay clear complexion foundation – light but buildable coverage, stays on all day. I don’t think it really does anything as far as the acne-fighting claims, but I switched to this from way more expensive foundation after seeing a friend use it and have stuck with it for 6-8 years.
-ELF eyelid primer – I actually use this under my eyes as well (but I have very fair skin) b/c I love the velvet texture
-ELF cream blush – not sure the exact name of this stuff but it is a dollar and it has great staying power. I usually layer under a powder blush (l’oreal true match, which is honestly probably not that amazing but I also poached this idea from the friend with the almay foundation and I’ve just stuck with it b/c it’s reliable) as it helps keep the powder blush on my face and when that inevitably fades there is a layer of the cream blush to back it up.
-some sort of l’oreal mascara – I switch up the actual type, but usually stick with some sort of l’oreal as I find they have the least fall out.
It was actually really interesting putting together this list because over the years I have bought SO many expensive beauty products – tons of Sunday Riley from Barneys, Oribe from Space NK, etc. etc. – but the only things I repeatedly purchase are from the drugstore. Maybe because I hold department store brands to a higher standard and nothing seems worth the money a second time?
Why is Nivea problematic?
They keep making dumb ads that imply that whiter/lighter skin is better. https://www.thecut.com/2017/10/nivea-natural-fairness-controversy.html
My go-to products:
Cetaphil Moisturizer SPF 15 – only sunscreen that doesn’t look ashy on my olive skin
Bobbi Brown Lip Color in Rose – great neutral
DermaBlend Pressed Powder – I wear it over foundation for additional coverage
I can’t live without Aveda LipSaver – all time greatest lip moisturizer. Put on a nice thick coat at bedtime and I wake up with soft smooth lips even in my ultra dry house in the middle of winter. I have tubes stashed everywhere and they also last a long time, completely worth the $10 price tag. I also love Aveda lipsticks in general but I’ve rarely been able to buy the same color, they seem to switch up most of the colors every year
Garnier Fructis dry shampoo – spray it on my dry hair at night and I wake up nicely volumnized. Made a world of difference to my fine wavy hair
Thanks for the rec!
Face/Skin:
CeraVe Foaming Facial Cleanser
Origins GinZing Eye Cream
Skinceuticals Physical Fusion UV Defense
Prescription retinol/lightener product compounded by a local pharmacy
Mario Badescu drying lotion for the occasional really bad pimple situation (yes, I know it has negatives, but nothing else really works for that giant zit that shows up the day before a formal event)
Neutrogena makeup remover towelettes (the only thing that gets off the Urban Decay eyeliner below without leaving a bunch of residue behind)
Vanicream for the bumps on the back of my arms
Makeup:
Urban Decay Eyeliner in Smoke, Ransom, and Rockstar
Urban Decay Eyeshadow in Gunmetal
Clinique Redness Solutions Loose Powder (not sure what I am going to do to cover my mild rosacea now that it has been discontinued, would love suggestions)
Bare Minerals Mineral Veil
Fresh Sugar Nude tinted lip balm
Hair
Tresemme Extra Hold Mousse (I buy 4-5 cans every time Target runs a gift card promo). I try all the fancy curly hair products and nothing holds as well in summer heat.
I wear very little makeup on the regular, so I bounce around on most colors and products.
This is a good subject . . . it is helpful to know what is tried and true!!
Skin (I’m normal-oily, over 40):
Paula’s Choice 2% BHA Lotion
Paula’s Choice RESIST Super Light Wrinkle Defense SPF 30
Simple Radiance Cleansing wipes
Makeup
I wear little and am fickle
Hair
Batiste dry shampoo – finally found a cheaper substitute as effective as Khlorane!
Clairol Shimmer Lights Shampoo – for toning down brassiness in highlights, works incredibly well
John Frieda Volumizing Mousse
Nature’s Gate shampoo/conditioner (I like the smell and the price. My hair is somewhat oily so I’m low maintenance here)
I must be really boring. When I find a product I like, I stick with it. Forever. I wear:
– Elizabeth Arden foundation. Whichever is the sheerer one.
– Bobbi Brown pale pink pot for cheeks
– Benefit Boing concealer
– Cover Girl smudgable eye pencil in brown-black
– Maybeline Great Lash mascara in blackest black
– MAC lipstick in Twig when I’m feeling actual color. Tarte lip paint in Birthday Suit for evening when I want to play up my eyes. And Sugar Honey for most days.
– Laura Mercier translucent powder
– Cetaphil cleanser for my face, followed at night by Olay Regenerist sculpting cream.
– L’Occitane hand cream in winter
I try new things, but I do tend to finish what I buy unless I absolutely hate it (rare). Here are my go-tos that I always have:
Skincare:
Clairins cleansing milk
Kiehl’s SPF 30 moisturizer
Jack Black lip balm (the mint stick one)
Makeup:
Laura Mercier Setting Powder in Medium Deep (thank you for a setting powder for WOC)
Laura Mercia Longwear foundation (nutmeg)
NARS matte lip pencil in Cruella
Estee Lauder Sumptuous Infinite Mascara
Milani eye pencils
Haven’t found an eyeshadow I stick with, but like my Smashbox Master Class palette
Suncare:
Shiseido sunscreen lotion (SPF 50+)
I used to ❤️ Queen Helene mint julep masque! Is it even around? As a teen, I had greasy skin and it REALLY pulled out the dirt and grime!! My high school boyfriend even started to use it!?
Amazing product!
My mom gave me some when I was in high school, as I also had oiley skin. I would use it again, even though I wound up falling asleep with a green face, and wakeing up with dry green masque all over my pillow case! Dad said I looked even scarier with masque then I did normally! I think that was a complement! YAY DAD!
Skincare:
Cerave foaming cleanser
EltaMD spf 40
Garnier micellar water
Smith’s rosebud salve
Eucerin hand cream
Makeup:
L’Oréal voluminous mascara (I do cheat with other variations and love the newest one)
Lancôme undereye concealer
L’Oréal true match concealer stick
Fresh lip balms in rose, fig, and petal
Dr. Jart BB balm in gold tube
Laura mercier caviar eyeshadow stick in amethyst
My holy grail always-repurchase products:
Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Dry Shampoo
Cover Girl Last Blast mascara
L’Oreal Lumi Cushion Foundation
Simple Skin Cleansing Facial Wipes
L’Oreal Quick Dry Primer Spray (swear it saves me a few minutes of blowdrying time)
Fekkai Brilliant Glossing Creme
Smith’s Rosebud Salve
Bite Agave Lip Mask
Soap & Glory Hand Food
First Aid Beauty Eye Duty Triple Remedy
First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Cream
I am SHOCKED that no one has listed Clinique City Block yet! That green tube is my ride-or-die every single day.
It provides sheer coverage (a little bit heavier than tinted moisturizer), SPF 40 and a dewy finish. It’s at Sephora, but I always buy it from an airport duty-free shop on vacation every April – this also ensures I’m not keeping a tube longer than a year.
My job has physical days and desk days, so on a desk day I’ll add mascara, tinted Burt’s Bees and a bit of e.l.f. blush to avoid looking dead. On physical days, my natural flush is enough and also I don’t care.
After going through a ton of moisturizers for my weird oily-dry skin, I’m on my third tube of Dr. Jart’s Water Drop.
When I travel for work, I take the tiniest make-up bag I can with the other four things I’ve bought multiple times:
-Maybelline’s weird little Instant Age Rewind Make-up treatment (light coverage but just that little bit more than bb cream)
-Bobbi Brown travel compact with their three brown nudes and blush
-Eyeko eyeliner pen (the only liner I can get a solid wing out of every time)
-Covergirl midnight brown brown pencil (I have bought the fancy brow stuff and I always end up back at this one because it looks so natural)
Olay Shea Butter body wash
Paula’s Choice 2% BHA – made a huge difference in my acne prone skin
Kerastase Ciment Thermique blow dry lotion
Bobbi Brown Skin foundation
Supergoop facial sunscreen
NARS Matte Multiple sticks (not shimmery!)
Glossier Boy Brow
RMS Beauty Beauty oil (just bought a new bottle today) Dove soap, Vaseline with shea butter.
Philosophy purity made simple cleanser
Mario Badescu Rose Facial Mist
Mario Badescu Glycolic Toner
Nyx microbrow pencil
It Cosmetics CC Cream
TheBalm Bad Gal Lash mascara
Soap and Glory The Righteous Butter body butter
Dove beauty finish dry spray deodorant
Tresemme keratin smooth spray
Skin:
Caudalie Instant Foaming Cleanser face wash
Tatcha Camellia Oil makeup remover
La Roche Posay Toleriane Sensitive Fluid moisturizer
EltaMD Clear sunscreen
For Fun:
Herbivore Blue Tansy Face Mask
Caudalie Crushed Cabernet Body Scrub
Briogeo Avocado and Kiwi Hair Mask
Skincare:
The Ordinary niacimide + zinc
Elta MD 41 tinted sunscreen (basically sheer foundation for me)
Hair:
Head & Shoulders classic + Aussie 3 minute miracle
Makeup
MaxFactor Clump Defy in the mauve tube (hard to find!)
NYX eyeliner stick in dark brown
CoverGirl stick concealer (looks like a lipstick)
NARS the multiple (portofino or maui)
Skincare:
*Cerave Foaming Gel cleanser
*Cerave Moisturizing Balm (use for face and body)
*Paula’s Choice 2% BHA
*Paula’s Choice Calm Toner
*Purito Centella SPF
*Hada Labo Hyalurone serum
*La Roche Toleriane tinted moisturizer
*Shiseido Oil Cleanser
*RetinA
*Aquaphor as foot cream for night
Haircare:
*Wella Pro Elements sulphate-free shampoo
*Matrix Pro Results Damaged hair mask
*Chi Keratine serum (as a heat protectant and filler for damaged hair)
Makeup:
*MAC studio fix makeup
*MAC studio powder
*Lancome Pret a Porter Waterproof mascara
*Maybelline lipstick in Hollywood red 540
and as always: Elmex Fluoride Gel
I’m very low maintenance but have oily, acne-prone skin.
Skin:
Environ Sebuwash (was recommended at a Canyon Ranch facial–haven’t bought another facewash since!)
Neutrogena HydroBoost water gel (summer) and gel cream (winter)
M-61 PowerGlow peel wipes
Makeup:
CoverGirl lashblast mascara (the orange tube)
Other than that, I tend to change it up, but usually stick to Bobbi Brown products. Only exception: shortly before lockdown, I got introduced to Estee Lauder doublewear foundation, and I haven’t worn it much due to WFH but I’m pretty sure I’m never looking back!
Skincare (Dry, sensitive skin):
– Cerave hydrating cleanser
– Sunday Riley CEO vitamin C serum
– Dr. Jart Ceramidin cream
– Clinique Moisture Surge overnight mask
– Farmacy hydrating sheet mask
– Bite Beauty Agave lip balm & overnight lip mask
Hair (Greying, thick, straight but can get frizzy/puffy)
– evo Mane Tamer conditioner
– IGK Crybaby smoothing serum
A number of my favorite products were discontinued, so I am trying all the samples.
Mac Rebel lipstick – my signature color for almost 10 ears. Truly my perfect color.
Lush R+B cream for my hair – smells amazing, conditions, defrizzes!
almost everything else is swappable depending on my mood!